George Boole died when his daughter Alicia was only four years old and, unable to support herself without a husband, his widow Mary left Ireland with four of her five daughters to live in London. There she took a job as a librarian at Queen's College, the first women's college in England, but also used her knowledge of mathematics and teaching methods to act as an unofficial tutor to the students. However, she left Alicia in Cork to live with her maternal grandmother. Alicia she was brought up partly by her grandmother, partly by her great-uncle, but these were years when she felt repressed and unhappy. When she was eleven years old she went to London where she joined her mother and sisters. However, the family were living in difficult circumstances in a crowded house. Coxeter writes :-
... the five girls were reunited with their mother (whose books reveal her as one of the pioneers of modern pedagogy) in a poor, dark, dirty, and uncomfortable lodging in London.Mary Boole was forced to leave her job as a librarian and became a secretary to James Hinton (1822-1875), a surgeon and author, and father of the mathematician Charles Howard Hinton who married Alicia's oldest sister Mary Ellen in 1880. James Hinton needed help with mathematical ideas for a project he was undertaking on philosophy. When Alicia was sixteen, in 1876, she returned to Cork for a short while where she worked in a children's hospital. However, after a short spell, she returned to London to live with her mother.
Although Alicia had no formal education, she was taught by her mother Mary. This was no ordinary education for Mary had her own ideas about teaching in general and about teaching mathematics in particular. Coxeter writes :-
There was no possibility of education in the ordinary sense, but Mrs Boole's friendship with James Hinton attracted to the house a continual stream of social crusaders and cranks.If we are to gain some idea about the teaching that Alicia received from her mother, we must look at Mary Boole's ideas about teaching. She wrote several books which were published much later but she certainly had the ideas for them when unofficially tutoring at Queen's College. Examples of these books are (i) Logic Taught By Love (1890), (ii) Lectures on the Logic of Arithmetic (1903), (iii) The preparation of the child for science (1904), and (iv) Philosophy and the fun of algebra (1909). Here are some quotes which are relevant to Alicia's education. the first quote is from (ii) the rest are from (iii):-
Anything which the teacher intends to prove should never be stated; children should be led up to find it out for themselves by successive questions.With no formal education she surprised everyone when, at the age of eighteen, she was introduced to a set of little wooden cubes by her brother-in-law Charles Howard Hinton. At this time Hinton was thinking about the article What is the fourth dimension? which he published in 1880. Alicia Boole experimented with the cubes and soon developed an amazing feel for four dimensional geometry. She introduced the word 'polytope' to describe a four dimensional convex solid. Coxeter writes :-
The geometric education may begin as soon as the child's hands can grasp objects. Let him have, among his toys, the five regular solids and a cut cone.
As soon as the hands can hold steadily compasses and set-square the child should be encouraged both in copying diagrams ... and in inventing others for himself. It is desirable that, before any systematic teaching of mathematics begins, the compass, set-square, and ruler marked in fractions of an inch should be as familiar implements as the fork and spoon.
Between the time when a child handles an actual cube, cuts sections etc., and the time when he comes, among his ordinary geometrical exercises, to problems requiring him to draw the elevation of a cube cut in some particular way, there is a period when he finds it useful, and very delightful, to go through a set of processes in imagination and to express them in his own words.
[James] Hinton's son Howard, brought a lot of small wooden cubes, and set the youngest three girls the task of memorising the arbitrary list of Latin words by which he named them, and piling them into shapes. To Ethel, and possibly Lucy too, this was a meaningless bore; but it inspired Alice (at the age of about eighteen) to an extraordinarily intimate grasp of four-dimensional geometry.Des MacHale, in , writes:-
She found that there were exactly six regular polytopes on four dimensions and that they are bounded by 5, 16 or 600 tetrahedra, 8 cubes, 24 octahedra or 120 dodecahedra. She then produced three-dimensional central cross-sections of all the six regular polytopes by purely Euclidean constructions and synthetic methods for the simple reason that she had never learned any analytic geometry. She made beautiful cardboard models of all these sections. ...Let us note at this point that Howard Hinton published the book A new era of thought in 1888. Alicia Boole wrote part of the preface of this book and also wrote some of the chapters on sections of 3-dimensional solids. By the time this book was published, Hinton had gone with Mary Ellen to Japan following his conviction for bigamy. Let us quote at this point a description by Geoffrey Taylor of how Alicia discovered the six regular polytopes on four dimensions (see ):-
Alice's method of discovery was typically that of an amateur. She started by noticing that a corner in a regular four-dimensional figure bounded by tetrahedra, for instance, can only have either 4, 8 or 20 of them meeting at a point because a section of three-dimensional space close to the corner in a symmetrical position could only be a tetrahedron, an octahedron, or an icosahedron. She then traced, using only Euclid's construction, the progress of the section as the four-dimensional figure passed through our three-dimensional space. In this way Alice, employing only Euclid's constructions, produced sections of all the six regular polytopes.After taking up secretarial work near Liverpool in 1889 Alicia Boole met and married the actuary Walter Stott in 1890; they had two children, Mary Stott (1891-1982) and Leonard Stott (1892-1963). However, life was hard and she "led a life of drudgery, rearing her two children on a very small income". Through her husband, Stott learned of Pieter Hendrik Schoute's work on central sections of the regular polytopes in 1895 and Alicia Stott sent him photographs of her cardboard models. Schoute was amazed to see Stott's models and immediately proposed meeting her in England. He came to England for his summer holidays over the next few years and stayed with Stott at the home of her maternal cousin in Hever. Schoute worked with Alicia Stott for almost 20 years, persuading her to publish her results which she did in two papers published in Amsterdam. These are On certain series of sections of the regular four-dimensional hypersolids (1900) and Geometrical deduction of semiregular from regular polytopes and space fillings (1910). She also wrote three papers jointly with Schoute, namely On Models of 3-dimensional sections of regular hypersolids in space of 4 dimensions (1907), On the sections of a block of eight-cells by a space rotating about a plane (1908), and Over wederkeerigheid in verband met halfregelmatige polytopen en netten (1910). Alicia Stott made two further important discoveries relating to constructions for polyhedra related to the golden section. She did not stop working at this point for a letter she wrote to Geoffrey Taylor in 1911 described, very modestly, her continuing work (see ):-
... I have not done anything more interesting than staining very shabby floors and such like homehold things for some time; but last night I received by post a M.S. of 70 very closely written pages containing an analytical counterpart of my last geometrical paper. Of course I must read it. It is the second attempt and was only written because I did not like the first but I am such a duffer at analytical work anyhow that I don't suppose I shall like this very much better.Schoute died in April 1913 and at this point Stott's work on polytopes seems to stop. However, the University of Groningen honoured her by inviting her to attend the tercentenary celebrations of the university and awarding her an honorary doctorate on 1 July 1914. She was proposed for the doctorate by Johan Antony Barrau (1873-1953) who was appointed to succeed Schoute at Groningen. Having read her papers he wrote (see ):-
From these papers, one infers a very special gift for seeing the position and forms in a space of four dimensions. Three of these papers are written jointly with late Professor Dr P H Schoute connected during so many years to the University of Groningen; And this fruitful cooperation with the professor that she lost, is the reason for the Faculty of Mathematics and Physics to propose Mrs A Boole Stott for the doctorate honoris causa in Mathematics and Physics, to confer on the occasion of the coming festive commemoration of the 300th birthday of the University.It was arranged for Stott to say with Schoute's widow when she came to Groningen to attend the celebrations and receive the honorary degree. However, for some reason that remains unclear, she did not travel to Groningen and the degree was awarded 'in absentia'.
In around 1930 she was introduced to Coxeter and they worked together on various problems :-
Coxeter's alliance with Aunt Alice was a great source of joy. "The strength and simplicity of her character," he said, "combined with the diversity of her interests to make her an inspiring friend." They conducted an ongoing conversation about polytopes, by letter and with visits back and forth.He even persuaded her to talk at Henry Baker's tea party :-
When Coxeter's turn came up for another session at Baker's tea party, he invited his "Aunt Alice" to deliver a joint lecture. ... When Aunt Alice made her appearance as Coxeter's guest at Baker's tea party, she brought her models and donated them to the department for permanent exhibit.After one of Coxeter's visits to Aunt Alice for "tea and polytopes" she gave him a present of two matching lamps with bases in the form of truncated icosahedra. When Coxeter left England to take up a post in Toronto in 1936 he received a present from Stott in the form of an antique stained-glass Archimedian solid lampshade. She wrote him a letter saying (see ):-
My dear! I don't know how to write to you - words seem so futile beside so great a separation! But indeed one can rejoice, for your sake, that it happened so ... While I have been writing my mind has gone back to the lovely world we have visited together, and which you have made so much your own. I wonder where you will get to in it! How I wish I could follow.When I [EFR] visited Donald Coxeter in Toronto in 1976 he spoke to me with great feeling about his discussions with Alice Boole Stott. He showed me models of her polytopes but I am unsure now if these were models she had made or whether they were models he had made in the same form as Stott.
Article by: J J O'Connor and E F Robertson