Ernst Witt

Born: 26 June 1911 in Alsen (German Baltic island) (now Als, Denmark)
Died: 3 July 1991 in Hamburg, Germany

Click the picture above
to see a larger version

Show birthplace location

Previous (Chronologically) Next Main Index
Previous (Alphabetically) Next Biographies index

Version for printing

Ernst Witt's parents were Heinrich Witt and Charlotte Jepsen. Heinrich Witt's father, also named Heinrich Witt, was a school teacher passionately dedicated to religious education in schools. Heinrich Witt, Ernst's father, was the seventh of thirteen children and his very religious upbringing led him to study theology at Halle University. He always intended to become a missionary and, after the Liebenzell Mission was set up in Hamburg in November 1899 they appointed Heinrich Witt to be their first missionary in China in March 1900. He went to Yuan-Chow and, in 1906, married Charlotte Jepsen from Sonderburg. They had a daughter who was born in China, and the family returned to Germany for their first leave home in 1911. It was during this two years leave that Ernst was born on the island of Alsen. Alsen together with the rest of North Schleswig became part of Germany in 1864. The island and was returned to Denmark by plebiscite in 1920, nine years after Witt's birth there, and is now known as Als. The island is separated from the Sundeved peninsula of southern Jutland by a narrow piece of water called Als Sound.

When Ernst was two years old, his parents returned to China to continue their missionary work. Heinrich Witt became head of the Liebenzell Mission in Changsha. Ernst spent the next nine years of his life in China with his elder sister and four younger siblings. He learnt Chinese from the Chinese nannies employed to look after the children, and he also learn arithmetic from his father. However, Heinrich Witt was very involved in his missionary work which took him on many long journeys through China. His children were somewhat neglected. First Heinrich sent his eldest daughter back to Germany to live with his brother in Müllheim. Then in the spring of 1920 Ernst and his younger brother Otto were also sent to live with their uncle in Müllheim. His uncle was a preacher with eight children of his own and he ran a home for children of missionaries - usually there were at least 30 children in total. The home was strictly run and did not provide a very stimulating environment for the young Witt. However he was now able to attend the Realschule in Müllheim where his enthusiasm for mathematics soon became evident as did his liking for chemistry.

After graduating from the Realschule in Müllheim, Witt went to Freiburg in 1927 were he attended the Oberrealschule. At this time his parents returned from China for another two year leave and they were in Germany for the years when Witt was at the Oberrealschule. At this school Witt was fortunate to have a talented mathematics teacher, Karl …ttinger, who quickly realised the extraordinary talent of his pupil and did everything he could to allow him to progress rapidly to advanced topics. In 1929 Witt's parent returned to China leaving all their children in Germany. Witt took his Abitur examination in the same year, then entered the University of Freiburg to study mathematics and physics. At Freiburg he was taught by, among others, Alfred Loewy and Oskar Bolza. It was usually for students at German universities at this time to move between institutions and after two terms at Freiburg, Witt moved to Göttingen for the start of the 1930 summer term. He attended lectures by Gustav Herglotz, Hermann Weyl, James Franck and Emmy Noether. Herglotz quickly realised that Witt had remarkable mathematical gifts. Having seen a remarkably simple proof by Witt of Wedderburn's theorem that every finite skew field is commutative, Herglotz encouraged him to submit it for publication and it became Witt's first paper appearing in 1931. Emil Artin, who held the chair at Hamburg, lectured at Göttingen in 1932 and Witt attended his lectures on class field theory and was greatly influenced by them. At Artin's invitation he spent some time in Hamburg studying the class field theory of number fields.

On 30 January 1933 Hitler came to power. Witt joined the Nazi Party on 1 May 1933 and also the SA, the military wing of the Party. It has been claimed that Oswald Teichmüller, who was like Witt a student at Göttingen, convinced him to join. Emmy Noether, who was Jewish, was dismissed from her post by the Nazis but continued to give lectures in her home. At one of the lectures Witt turned up wearing his SA (Sturm Abteilung: Storm Section) uniform. His doctorate was obtained from Göttingen where his doctoral studies were officially supervised by Herglotz. However, it was Emmy Noether who suggested a topic related to the Riemann-Roch theorem and this was indeed the topic on which his dissertation Riemann-Rochscher Satz und Z-Funktion im Hyperkomplexen was written. The oral exemination was held at the end of July 1933; the committee comprising Herglotz, Weyl and the physicist Robert Pohl. He had written up the thesis in the first week of July and submitted it on the 7th. He published his thesis in 1934 in Mathematische Annalen. Herglotz wrote in 1946 about Witt's activities in the SA (see for example [7]). He:-

... joined the SA, urged on by the simple wish ... not to stand apart, while others carried their burden. I asked him about his impression of his comrades, whose ideas, as I suspected, would often come into conflict with his devotion to science. His answer was: "I don't know much about them. During our night marches I never talk to them, and in the morning I go home immediately, to continue my studies where I left them the evening before." In those days we had much trouble with certain 'activists', particularly among the younger lecturers. I would like to emphasize the fact that Witt always stood apart from this group and its troublemaking. He was completely absorbed in his mathematical work, which he only interrupted for night and pack marches. The way he looked at the time caused quite a bit of worry.

This view that Witt put mathematics before Nazi ideology is born out by many, both staunch Nazi supporters and those opposed to the Nazi ideas. The pro-Nazi Werner Weber wrote about Witt:-

... Witt once explained that all sciences can reshape themselves in accordance with the spirit of the times; only in mathematics must everything remain as before.

Weyl resigned his professorship at Göttingen, and after arguments between hard-line Nazis and some who were less hard-line, Helmut Hasse was offered the chair which he took up in 1934. Witt joined Hasse's seminar on congruence function fields and p-adic numbers; he was appointed as Hasse's assistant. Oswald Teichmüller and Ludwig Schmid were also members of the seminar, and Schmid collaborated with Witt on ideas which would lead to the Witt vector calculus. Witt habilitated with Hasse in 1936. In February of that year he took an oral examination and gave his habilitation lecture in June 1936. Kersten writes [7]:-

His habilitation on the theory of quadratic forms in arbitrary fields ranks as one of his most famous works. In it he introduced what was later named the 'Witt ring' of quadratic forms. Shortly after that, Witt introduced the ring of 'Witt vectors', which had a great influence on the development of modern algebraic geometry (see [4] and [5]).

The Nazis dismissed Otto Toeplitz from his chair in Bonn in 1935. In the following year Herglotz argued strongly in support of Witt becoming Toeplitz's successor but the chair was not filled until 1939 when Wolfgang Krull was appointed. Witt published Treue Darstellung Liescher Ringe in 1937, which was inspired by earlier work of Wilhelm Magnus on free Lie algebras. In this paper Witt showed that any Lie algebra over a field has a faithful representation in an associative algebra, and that there exists an associative algebra which is universal with respect to this construction. This, together with results of Poincaré from 1899 and Birkhoff in 1937 (independently of Witt), led to the famous Poincaré-Birkhoff-Witt theorem (see [3] for the history of the theorem). Murray Bremner writes:-

The Poincaré-Birkhoff-Witt theorem gives an explicit description of the universal associative enveloping algebra of any Lie algebra over any field, and thereby establishes a remarkable relation between associative and nonassociative algebras. It is one of the most important theorems in mathematics, connecting such diverse areas as representation theory, differential geometry, and universal algebra.

In August 1937 he attended the compulsory National Socialist course for lecturers and was given the follow assessment (see [7]):-

National Socialist thinking: Mediocre
Independent propagandist in any situation: No
National Socialist disposition: Limited
Physical capabilities: weakly-built, cannot be established because of a sporting injury.
General enthusiasm for his duty: shirker
Behaviour towards people around him: quiet, restrained, his manners are somewhat insecure.
Description of his character: Witt has shown himself to be quiet, modest and restrained, with a tendency to keep to himself; characteristic features are a certain naivety and eccentricity. He is honest and straightforward. He dedicates himself to his work with dogged tenacity, continuously brooding and thinking and thus represents the typical, politically indifferent researcher and scientist, who will probably be successful in his subject, but who, at least for the time being, is lacking any of the qualities of a leader or educator.

Emil Artin was not a Jew but his wife was a Jew so when the "New Official's Law" was passed by the Nazis in 1937 affecting those who were related to Jews by marriage he was forced from his post at the University of Hamburg. Artin left Germany for the United States. Witt was appointed to fill the vacancy at Hamburg in 1938, at first as a lecturer, then from 1 September 1939 as an extraordinary professor. He remained there until he retired in 1979. In 1940 he married Erna Bannow, from Göttingen. She was a mathematician who had gone to work with Artin in Hamburg; they had two daughters. Erna Bannow's doctoral dissertation Die Automorphismengruppen der Cayley-Zahlen was published in 1940 as was Witt's report on the thesis.

Witt was called up for war service in February 1940 but managed to get it deferred for a year. From February 1941 he trained as a radio operator and in June was sent to the Russian front. However he became ill and, in November, was sent back to Germany. He recovered from the illness, after which he was sent to undertake decoding work in Berlin. At the end of the war he was taken prisoner, but still in 1945 was freed to return to Hamburg. However, he was dismissed from his professorship at Hamburg because of his association with the Nazis. Many of his colleagues wrote supporting his reinstatement, all testifying that Witt, despite his membership of the Party, had quickly realised that the aims of the Nazi Party were incompatible with scientific progress which was always the most important thing in his life. He was reinstated in April 1947, appointed as a personal professor in 1954 and a full professor in 1957. He retired on 30 September 1979. We note that following the two papers Spiegelungsgruppen und Aufzählung halbeinfacher Liescher Ringe and Eine Identität zwischen Modulformen zweiten Grades, both published in 1941, no further publications by Witt appeared until 1949 when he published Rekursionsformel für Volumina sphärischer Polyeder.

Witt made many visits to lecture on his work. He lectured in Spain and, as a consequence of these lectures, published two expository papers in Spanish: On Zorn's theorem (1950), and Intuitionistic mathematics (1951). Among other visits, usually to give lecture courses, we mention Rome (December 1952 to April 1953), Barcelona (autumn 1953), and Istanbul (spring 1958). He spent the academic year 1960-61 at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton in the United States. Witt was always completely honest and often rather naive, and he showed this side of his character during his time in Princeton. He is supposed to have shown around his driver's licence, which was authorised with a swastika, without realising that it would cause offence. In spring 1961 Kurosh and Witt were introduced in Princeton. Kurosh had lectured about a theorem of Witt's and, when told that, Witt smiled and said "I proved that theorem when I was in the USSR". Kurosh replied in a friendly way "Why, I never knew you visited the USSR. When was that?" Witt replied "When I was in the Wehrmacht". Kurosh turned on his heel and left without a word. Witt never quite understood why his openness about such matters led to his colleagues at Princeton avoiding him.

Witt's work was mainly concerned with quadratic forms and various related fields such as algebraic function fields, Witt vectors, Lie rings and Mathieu groups. He is best known for his introduction of Witt vectors which appeared in his paper in 1936 in J. Reine Angew. Math. The original construction of Witt vectors is given in the articles [4] and [5] ([4] is a German translation of [5]). The papers [6], [7] and [8] are written by Ina Kersten who was one of Witt's pupils at Hamburg and his assistant during the two years before he retired. Kersten describes Witt's final years [7]:-

Since 1969, he suffered from allergies to various detergents and adhesives for wallpapers and carpets. He complained about dizziness and a diminishing ability to concentrate. Because of these troubles, he had to decline several invitations for talks at home and abroad, and in 1975, he experienced a slight stroke. Moreover, because of his allergies, he could not join the move of the mathematics department to a modern high-rise building, in which, because of some kind of air conditioning, the windows could not be opened. Thus he got more and more isolated, and his general reputation to be an eccentric was strengthened. On his account the colloquia of the mathematics department were held in another building, and he could attend them until shortly before his death.

Witt received many honours such as membership of the German Mathematical Society (Deutsche Mathematiker-Vereinigung) in 1937, the Hamburg Mathematical Society, the oldest mathematical society in the world which still exists today, in 1954, and the Göttingen Academy of Sciences in 1978.

We end this biography by quoting Segal [2]:-

Ernst Witt seems to have actually suited a usual caricature of a mathematician - both heedless and ignorant of the world, somewhat naive, self-absorbed in his mathematical universe, truly unpolitical. This is also a caricature sometimes used to explain academic reaction to the Nazis. In both cases it is almost always false. Witt is worth consideration because his life seems to show that the caricatures could, in fact, both be true.

Article by: J J O'Connor and E F Robertson

Click on this link to see a list of the Glossary entries for this page

List of References (8 books/articles)

Mathematicians born in the same country

Other Web sites
  1. Mathematical Genealogy Project

Previous (Chronologically) Next Main Index
Previous (Alphabetically) Next Biographies index
Famous curves Societies, honours, etc. History Topics
Mathematicians of the day Birthplace maps

JOC/EFR © April 2009
Copyright information
School of Mathematics and Statistics
University of St Andrews, Scotland

The URL of this page is: